ABOUT Orange Lake
Orange Lake, New York in brief
Municipal facts for project context.
- Orange Lake is a hamlet and census-designated place in the western part of the Town of Newburgh in Orange County, sitting on the eastern shore of the lake it is named for.
- Orange Lake was one of the faster-growing communities in the Hudson Valley in the 2010s — its population jumped 39.9 percent between the 2010 and 2020 censuses, from 6,982 to 9,770 residents.
- Native Americans called the lake "Oussuk," meaning "stony pond," while Dutch settlers called it "Binnin," meaning water within land; in 1684, Governor Thomas Dongan bought the lake and surrounding territory from the Native Americans and divided it into farms, mostly dairy farms.
- During the Revolutionary War era, Captain Thomas Machin owned and operated a sawmill, a gristmill, and even a mint at the outlet of the lake in what is now the hamlet, and a historical marker on Lakeside Road marks the site of Machin's Mill.
- The lake only became known as Orange Lake in the 1830s, when a local clergyman named James R. Willson began using the name — probably in honor of Orange County, and possibly because the lake is round like an orange — and local legend says many residents objected to the change.
- Because the lake sits about 800 feet above sea level, its outlet stream became a popular site for mills, the largest of which was the Newburgh Bleachery, operated by the Chadwick family.
- Trolley service reached Orange Lake in 1895, when it became the halfway stop on the line between the City of Newburgh and the Village of Walden, and a highly successful amusement park soon opened on the lake's south shore; the trolley stopped running in 1926 and the park was demolished in 1941.
- The Pine Point resort on a peninsula off the lake's southern shore was a big-band-era hotspot where nationally known acts including Frank Sinatra and Benny Goodman performed; it opened in 1896 and was demolished in 1953.
- In the late 1940s, novelist Mickey Spillane lived in a house he built on Rock Cut Road in Orange Lake and wrote his first novel, I, the Jury, while living there.
- A one-room schoolhouse built in 1849 served Orange Lake children until the local system merged into the Newburgh Enlarged City School District in 1963; today the CDP is split among the Newburgh, Valley Central, and Wallkill school districts.