ABOUT Swan Lake
Swan Lake, New York facts
Municipal background for project planning. Facts are context, not coverage.
- Swan Lake is a hamlet and census-designated place in the town of Liberty, Sullivan County, in the Catskill Mountains — and despite the name, it has nothing to do with swans or the famous ballet.
- The community was originally called Stevensville, after the Stevens brothers, who built a large sole-leather tannery there; their name was formally adopted at a residents' meeting on January 24, 1848.
- The lake itself was created by damming the Mongaup River in the 1840s to supply water to the tannery, and it eventually grew to more than 600 acres.
- Swan Lake's post office opened in 1849, when the community was still known as Stevensville.
- Around 1895 Brooklyn businessman Alden S. Swan acquired the lake and much of the surrounding land, and in January 1927 the community and its post office were renamed Swan Lake in his honor.
- A hotel and tourist industry took root in Swan Lake in the 1880s, making it part of the Catskills' famous Borscht Belt resort region.
- The lake drew national attention on July 31, 1937, when the body of a victim of a mob hit was recovered from its waters.
- A quirky local landmark is the Miniature Stone Castle, a small medieval-style stone castle built on the lakefront in the 1930s by an Italian immigrant master mason for the owners of the Commodore Hotel.
- Swan Lake is a very small year-round community: the 2020 census counted just 372 residents in the CDP.